A loan
workout is an agreement that is negotiated with your current lender
that changes the terms of your current loan. Lenders are willing to
negotiate when borrowers are facing financial difficulties and can't
obtain other financing alternatives. You must show the lender why it
would be in the lender's best interest to agree to a workout
arrangement. If convinced, a lender may be willing to reduce the loan
interest rate, reduce monthly payment amounts or change other loan
terms.
A loan
modification generally occurs where the parties to a problem loan
mutually agree to workout the problem by creating new and better loan
terms. The hope is that the new loan will enable to the borrower to
meet their obligations.
When
applying for a loan modification, make a game plan on how exactly you
are going to approach them. These people are trained in minimizing loss
for their company and they get paid to by getting the most amount of
money out of you as possible or declare that your case is un workable
and foreclose on you. That is how they mitigate loss. If you understand
this, then you'll know that you have to approach them and all
conversations very carefully. Everything can and will be used against
you.
Items
You Will Need When Applying For a Loan Modification
Document
income and expenses. Keep all correspondence (even the envelopes)
Before negotiating a deal, gather all the information you need,
starting with any correspondence from your lender. That includes
anything that you have unopened from the lender. Don't throw away
envelopes from the servicer -- postmarks sometimes can make the
difference between being eligible or ineligible for relief.
Collect
everything that relates to income and expenses. Find your last four pay
stubs. They want to see at least one month of income. If your income is
very sporadic, the support your story by showing how you're getting
paid so we can calculate an average over time. Gather at least three
years worth of W2s and tax returns, plus three to six months of bank
statements. Find all the mortgage paperwork and add that to the file.
Pull together all bills, paid or not, from the times you were falling
behind on the house payments until now. Include utilities, auto
payments, credit cards, student loans, child support, medical bills.
Find the winter and summer heating and cooling bills. You need to also
include everything that documents why you fell behind. An employer's
notification of reduced hours or a layoff, an invoice for an auto
repair or a furnace replacement, a shutoff notice from a utility.
What
to Do When You Call Your Lender:
Your
lender has two platoons of employees who talk with delinquent
borrowers. The first is the collections department, which consists of
people who try to pry money out of you and get you current on the
payments. The second group consists of the loss mitigation specialists.
These departments go by different names, depending on the servicer,
including foreclosure prevention, loan resolution and delinquency
customer service. We'll use the most common name for the department:
loss mitigation, or loss mit. It can be difficult to get through to the
loss mitigation department if collection agents are discouraged from
transferring calls. This is one of the benefits of having a helper,
such as an attorney or a housing counselor. The first will intimidate
bill collectors and the second might have contacts within the loss
mitigation department.
The
trick with any bank and getting a work out done is learning to navigate
their phone system so as to increase your chances of getting a live
person. Over the years I’ve learned some tricks that help,
sometimes you hear options that you know will lead to a person like
when it says "to speak to a representative press ___" but sometimes
they don't give you these options. So, you have to think, what options
WOULD get a live person. For example often anything that involves new
clients signing up will get a live representative...because they always
want new business. You have to be a little savvy though; you
can’t just tell the sales guy you called them so you could
get a warm body to answer the phone!
Once
you get a live person, you want to be working your way up to a decision
maker. This is sometimes harder to do for a homeowner than a 3rd party.
Often with the homeowner they get stonewalled at the first level, and
sadly the first tier in Loss Mitigation is really a glorified
collections department. They are paid hourly employee's who have very
little if not zero motivation to go the extra mile and help you get
some needed comfort and relief while resolving your problem. Often they
just compound the problem by being rude and demanding, telling people
things like "just pay your bills". So it’s essential that you
get beyond these people and to a specialist.
Sometimes
to get to this point you have to put up with the hourly employee's
through a process of filling out their forms and information. Providing
them with items such as pay stubs, tax returns and a whole host of
financial information. Once everything is provided, then some lenders
will assign the file to someone higher up in the loss mitigation
department.
The
MOST crucial element to this whole process is your Budget and if you
have done your due diligence, you'll be ready . They will ask you for a
detailed list of your monthly expenses. If it’s too tight,
you may not get approved, if you have too much extra income you are
going to have an outrageous payment plan. Don't agree to it!
The
2nd MOST important thing you can do is DO NOT SPEND YOUR HOUSE
PAYMENTS. Often people stop making their payment because they are
falling behind on other bills, or they can’t quite make the
whole house payment. Over the years more often than not, the people I
met with still have an income coming in each month, they just
can’t meet all their obligations, so while the house is
falling behind they take advantage of the fact that they aren't paying
the house payment in order to catch up on other debts. THIS IS NOT WISE
AT ALL. Sock away as much of that money each month as you can. Its
crucial, here's why;
If you
don't pay your mortgage for 3-4 months and your lender decides to
negotiate a repayment plan or a loan modification, then they will want
what is called "good faith" money for you to come to the table with.
Typically this is from 30-75% and sometimes 100% of what you owe in
delinquent fees and attorney fees. Often I speak with homeowners who
spend all their money and have nothing to work with. If that is the
case, then don't expect them to work with you or you better have a
REAAAALLLY good explanation and proof as to why you have no money to
bring to the table.
We all
know life throws curve balls at us, it’s the nature of the
game, and you’d better just expect it, because it’s
coming in one form or another. Whether it be a car breaking down, an
illness, injury or death. An accident in a car, you just don't ever
know and it’s ALWAYS a good idea to have a rainy day fund.
The crazy thing about going into foreclosure is that you can actually
come out of it better off than you went in sometimes.
Is
it Better to Just Walk Away and Start Over?
Many
homeowners are just in over their heads. Many they love their home and
their family does too. But what good is it when you are so stressed out
that you cannot enjoy your home. You’re maxed out and you
don't have a dime to take the kids for an ice cream or the movies.
That's no way to live. This is a serious time to really sit down and
see if it's all really worth the stress and heart ache. If it's not
then maybe it's time to just throw in the towel and down size. Get
something you can afford and enjoy. Just close the door on this time in
your life and move on. Sure, it will affect you for years, but place
your health and well being before making a house payment. If this is
you, you're not alone. Think about it. Is it all really worth the pain
and stress? You're already down, maybe it's time to just move on and
take that money and get a nice little place to rent and regroup.
By
saving up your payment for 2-3 months or more depending on the
foreclosure time line in your state, you can not only have enough to
put together a really nice plan with your lender, but also have some in
the bank for a rainy day or worse case scenario, a rental. Often
payment plans with the bank can be pricey and very short terms, like 6
months total to repay what you fell behind on. The people if have
worked with who took my advice to save up and keep some funds in the
bank, were successful 100% of the time at keeping their home. Because
they were prepared for life's curve balls. Even though they had fallen
behind in the past, if they had an expense one month, they just pulled
a little from the slush fund in the bank to help supplement their house
payment that month.
The
Lender Has Made You a Deal, What Now?
Respond
to your lender, but don't be rushed into making a promise that you
can't keep. Before making a deal with your lender, describe your
situation to an attorney, accountant or a knowledgeable mortgage
person. You need to make sure that it is reasonable and not an
agreement that will stop
foreclosure for a month or
two.
Many
lenders are likely to offer forbearance. Theses are only good for a
short term band aid and not for the long term. Most commonly, this
entails adding a set amount to each month's payment. A forbearance plan
can go as long as 36 months. But many are set to fail and are
completely unreasonable for borrowers to pay back. Usually this will
require placing the delinquent amount on top of your monthly mortgage
payment. If you had trouble making your mortgage payment before, good
luck paying your new larger more unaffordable payment.
If all
else fails, seek out a third party to handle this for you. There are
many non-profit housing counselors, attorneys and for profits that are
very experienced in loan modifications and loan workouts.
Plan
to arrive at an agreement, but prepare for the unwelcome news that
you'll have to move out. If you turn over the deed in lieu of
foreclosure, or agree to a short sale (in which the lender lets you
sell the house for less than the mortgage balance), or are forced out
in a foreclosure action, you'll need to consult a lawyer and maybe an
accountant.
Don't
give up and fight to stop foreclosure and save your home! If all
efforts fail, it's not the end of the world. Just make sure that you
mitigate loss to you and do your best to save what little credit you
have left.
Good Luck!